Harrison Insurance and Financials, Ltd

101 E Bullion St, #2i
Hailey, ID 83333

Get Directions

Will Home Insurance Cover Damage Caused by Your Rental Tenants?

Owning a rental property means accepting that other people are living their lives inside your space. Sometimes that goes smoothly. Other times, damage shows up and raises the question of whether insurance should be involved. In Idaho, the answer depends on the type of damage and how it came to be.

Insurance Expectations for Rental Properties

Once a home is rented out, it’s typically insured under a landlord or dwelling policy. These policies are built around tenant occupancy, but they still focus on unexpected events. Home insurance through Harrison Insurance and Financials LTD, serving Hailey, ID, isn’t meant to absorb the cost of everyday use or gradual decline. It steps in when something sudden happens, not when a problem slowly develops.

Accidents Versus Ongoing Damage

If a tenant accidentally causes a fire, a major water release, or another abrupt incident tied to a covered cause, insurance may respond. The timing matters. Damage that happens all at once is viewed very differently than damage that builds over weeks or months. Slow leaks, ignored maintenance issues, or repeated misuse usually fall outside coverage.

When Damage Is Intentional

Deliberate damage creates a different situation. If a tenant vandalizes the property or intentionally causes harm, insurance commonly excludes it. In Idaho, those losses are often addressed through lease enforcement or legal action rather than an insurance claim.

Everyday Wear Is Part of Renting

Normal wear comes with the territory. Worn flooring, chipped paint, aging fixtures, and minor cosmetic issues are expected in rental housing. These aren’t insurance matters, even when repairs add up between tenants.

Tenant damage can be frustrating, but insurance isn’t a catch-all solution. Your insurance agent at Harrison Insurance and Financials LTD, serving Hailey, ID, can review your policy and help you understand how coverage aligns with the realities of renting out a home.

Our Partners


  • American Modern
  • Banner Life
  • Blue Cross of Idaho
  • Chubb
  • Dairyland
  • Encompass
  • Foremost
  • John Hancock
  • Kemper
  • Liberty Mutual
  • lloyds of London
  • MetLife
  • Mountain Health
  • Nationwide
  • Progressive
  • Protective
  • Safeco
  • Select Health
  • The Hartford
  • Travelers